Reform without Repeal

This is Ross Douthat starting with the March for Life, but quickly getting deeply wise and insightful real fast.

I tried to find an excerpt, but its a short op-ed to begin with. Each phrased seems necessary. This is just the conclusion…

For its part, if the pro-life movement wants not only to endure but to triumph, then it needs an answer to this argument. That means something more than just a defense of a universal right to life. It means a realist’s explanation of how, in policy and culture, the feminist revolution could be reformed without being repealed.

He’s right, and this is a call from a practicing Roman Catholic to recognize a couple of things about civil society. However much ongoing harm the sexual revolution has done, repealing it in civil society is not possible, and some portions of it none of us would want to repeal (I’m thinking the equal pay portions and the access to occupations). As Mr. Douthat starts his column, the heroic generation of this cause is passing away. Heroic generations are revolutionaries or in this case counter-revolutionaries. Our generation is about recognizing the limits of revolution. That doesn’t mean making peace with it, but it does mean being smart and finding the places where life can win and start being seen as legitimate reformers instead of calling for the whole structure to be removed by the axe at the root of the tree.

Pastor’s Corner – Newsletter from May 2012

Then he said to Thomas, “Put your finger here, and see my hands; and put out your hand, and place it in my side. Do not disbelieve, but believe.” – John 20:27 ESV

“Rich wounds, yet visible above, In beauty glorified” – LSB525, Crown Him with Many Crowns

Elsewhere in this newsletter my wife notes that I read a lot, so one of the most intriguing things to me has been the advent of the Kindle single or Kindle short. If you are a reader you’ve read those novels where the author had 40 great pages, but it doesn’t expand to a novel, but they had to make it 180 pages to justify printing and a $20 hardcover price tag. The Kindle short is electronic, so no printing costs. And it is usually selectively published – either by the author themselves or by experimental publishers. So, it can be priced around that magic $1 range. When the tag is $20, buying something you know little about just doesn’t happen. At a buck, sure, what the hell.

I stumbled across one the other day that is the deepest and most powerful meditation on sin, redemption, suffering and glory I’ve read in a long time and written in highly accessible language to boot. Poor Baby by Heather King is all of 28 pages. You will read it in one sitting, and not just because it is short.

I won’t steal Ms. King’s subject or reveal details, but I will quote a couple of lines. “Maturity means consenting to develop a conscience. Maturity means acknowledging that there are always consequences; there are always repercussions.” And, “Although perhaps no wound that deep ever exactly heals. A wound is accepted and incorporated, just as Christ’s wounds were incorporated – not removed, not erased, but incorporated – after the Resurrection.”

One other book dominating some mental cycles has been Ross Douthat’s Bad Religion. It is a sober examination of the decline of Christianity in America from roughly 1945. Its central thesis is American religion has been drowning in a sea of heresies. For some reason which Mr. Douthat does not really diagnose (he is a NYT columnist, and not a preacher), Americans have en masse chosen to chuck the orthodox faith and doctrine. His examination is spot on and can’t really be refuted. But he does not really venture in the project of why, or of what do we do, other than the logical conclusion of “turn back”.

It is the combination of the two books that gives the larger picture. Mr. Douthat is speaking to the head. He lays out that compelling case of the results of decades of heresy and attempting to soften the faith’s proclamation of both law and gospel. But Ms. King speaks to the heart. Doctrines and even heresies are cold things. Even looking at the results writ large in society is unmoving. Individual lives have scars and consequences and wounds. Ms. King shows us some of hers. And she shows us the warm and beating side of doctrines lived or failed, of wresting with easy heresies and soft lies, of finding comfort in hard truth.
At the end Poor Baby is itself an incarnation and an invitation. Come and see. Put your hands in these wounds. Stop disbelieving and believe. And contrary to orthodoxy’s cultured despisers, believing is the beginning of maturity. Believing is the beginning of actually seeing the wounds and not just wishing them away for the next sweet fix. In Christ, and in Christ alone, do we find wounds glorified.